In Nigeria's public secondary schools, classes are big and one-to-one tutoring is out of reach for most families. In June and July 2024, nine public schools in Benin City, Edo State, tried a cheaper stand-in. A lottery offered 657 first-year senior secondary students, most around 15, twelve 90-minute after-school sessions with an AI tutor, while 671 classmates kept to regular lessons.

The clever bit

The AI never worked alone. Students shared a computer in pairs and chatted with Microsoft Copilot, then running on GPT-4. Each session opened with a teacher's prompt tied to the national English curriculum. Teachers walked the room, kept pairs on task and helped them spot the AI's mistakes, and students were pushed to ask for explanations and examples instead of finished answers.

Hooray

Students offered the sessions scored 0.31 standard deviations higher on the end-of-program test, with gains in English (0.24) and in understanding AI (0.31). The gain showed up outside the program too: their regular third-term school English exam, which covered more than the sessions did, rose 0.21. Scores rose with attendance, and girls gained the most. The pilot cost about $48 per student.

1.5 to 2 years
of typical learning progress: the World Bank team's estimate of what the six-week gain equalsSource: blogs.worldbank.org

Then came the outside check. Researchers in Peru and Colombia who weren't part of the original study downloaded the World Bank's public data and code and rebuilt the analysis from the raw files. Their paper, published October 23, 2026, landed on the same 0.31 overall effect. It held when they reweighted for students who missed the final test, and stayed positive when they dropped each school in turn.

What comes next

The re-analysis flags one open question: students with fewer devices and less internet at home may have gained as much or more, because the school labs gave everyone the same access, but that estimate is too uncertain to call. Both teams want longer follow-up, other subjects, and tests in rural schools with weaker connections.